
On Feb. 10th, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame announced their latest list of finalists for the class of 2021. The voting is open to all at vote.rockhall.com. You can vote for up to five of the finalists and you are allowed to vote once daily until April 30th. Although the public is allowed to vote, getting the most votes by the public is no guarantee of induction to the class of ’21.
The sixteen finalists include Mary J. Blige, Kate Bush, the Foo Fighters, the Go-Go’s, DEVO, Iron Maiden, Jay-Z, Chaka Khan, Rage against the Machine, Todd Rundgren, Tina Turner, Dionne Warwick, Carole King, the New York Dolls, LL Cool J and Fela Kuti. The list is one of the most diverse fields nominated. But are they missing the boat of the meaning of the Hall in the first place?
Last year’s inductees include the Doobie Brothers, T-Rex, Nine Inch Nails, Depeche Mode, Whitney Houston and the Notorious BIG. Gone from last year’s list are Dave Matthews band, Pat Benatar, Soundgarden and Judas Priest, most notably.
Let’s discuss the elephant in the room. One could make a case for the worthiness of the body of work of all of the nominees, but is their music really Rock and Roll or a strong influencer? Mary J. Blige Jay-Z, Chaka Khan, Dionne Warwick, LL Cool J all have had great careers but is it Rock and Roll? Does anyone outside the Afro Beat fans and drummer’s world know who Fela Kuti is? Whatever happened to Rock and Roll? Their music is not played on most rock and roll radio stations. Let me reiterate, these are all major recording artists and concert attractions but is it Rock and Roll?
If elected, Tina Turner and Carole King will enter the Hall a second time as solo artists. Tina was elected in 1991 to the Hal for her early work as part of the Ike and Tina Turner revue and Carol King entered in 1990 as one half of a songwriting team with former husband Gerry Goffin. Dave Grohl would be a two-time winner, first in XXXX with Nirvana and maybe now with the Foo Fighters.
Should the Hall create categories such as Rap or Hip Hop, R&B or Early influences? What about Country, Jazz or even Classical artists? If we’re nominating Hip Hop artists, shouldn’t the hall consider the likes of jazz greats such as John Coltrane, Thelonious Monk or Louis Armstrong? Do you know that the ONLY jazz great in the Hall is Miles Davis? One of the most overlooked genres of Rock is Metal. Why not have a separate category for this and make sure to recognize a deserving artist or two each year?
Are any of the Hip Hop artists more of an influence on Rock and Roll than Dave Matthews or Pat Benatar? Many rock artists list jazz greats as influences. Shouldn’t that make the case for John McLaughlin or Herbie Hancock? I could go on for days but you get the point.
Should the Rock-N-Roll Hall be renamed as the Recording Artist Hall of Fame with nominees in separate categories and the worthiest from each category gaining admission? Is the Board ruining the Rock Hall by diluting the nominee list? I ask for your opinion on the subject?
FYI, artists become eligible for induction 25 years after the release of their first record. While fans get to vote on their favorites, winning the fan vote is no guarantee of election Just ask Dave Matthews, last year’s winner of the fan vote who is not even listed this year! The Rock Hall Board has the greatest influence on who gets in as who does not. Perhaps the decision makers need to pay more attention to the fans and not their egos.
Trivia question- Twenty-three artists have gained induction two times. Who’s the only artist to have been inducted three times? Reply with your answer!
#RockandRollHallofFame #MaryJBlige #KateBush #FooFighters @GoGo’s # DEVO #IronMaiden #Jay-Z #ChakaKhan #RageAgainstTheMachine #ToddRundgren #TinaTurner #DionneWarwick #Carole King #NewYorkDolls #LLCoolJ #FelaKuti #DoobieBrothers #T-Rex #NineInchNails #DepecheMode #WhitneyHouston #Notorious BIG #DaveMatthews #PatBenatar #Soundgarden #JudasPriest #JohnColtrane #Thelonious Monk #Louis Armstrong #MilesDavis #HerbieHancock #JohnMcLaughlin


















